The Feral Folklorist — Season 1, Episode 7
The Myrtles Plantation in St. Francisville, Louisiana, has been called one of the most haunted houses in America. Depending on which stories you hear, the property is home to several ghosts, including children, former owners, and an enslaved woman named Chloe.
Then there is the mirror.
Visitors have reported handprints, strange marks, unusual reflections, and the feeling that something on the other side of the glass is watching them. The story is tied to an old mourning custom that said mirrors should be covered when someone died in the house.
The Myrtles has enough ghost stories to fill several episodes, but what makes the place especially interesting is where history ends and folklore begins.
In this episode, I look at the house, some of its best-known ghosts, the famous mirror, and the old beliefs that may have helped turn an ordinary piece of glass into one of the most talked-about objects in Southern ghost lore.
What This Episode Explores
The Myrtles was built in 1796 by David Bradford, who had fled Pennsylvania after becoming involved in the Whiskey Rebellion. He called the property Laurel Grove, and the house eventually passed to his daughter Sarah Matilda and her husband, Clark Woodruff.
Like most wealthy Southern properties of the period, the plantation depended on enslaved labor. That part of its history sometimes gets pushed behind the ghost stories, but it is important when talking about a place that has accumulated so many legends about suffering, death, and unrest.
Several members of the Woodruff family died while living there, most likely from yellow fever. Later owners expanded the house into the Greek Revival mansion visitors recognize today.
One of the most famous Myrtles legends concerns Chloe, an enslaved woman often described as wearing a green head covering. Her story has become central to the haunting, even though there is no known historical record proving that she actually lived at the plantation.
That doesn’t mean the story disappeared.
Quite the opposite.
Visitors still report seeing a woman matching Chloe’s description, and her legend has become so connected with the Myrtles that it is difficult to talk about one without the other.
Another well-known story concerns William Drew Winter, who was shot at the house in 1871. Over time, a legend developed around his final moments and the staircase inside the home.
Then there is the mirror.
Old mourning customs in the South and elsewhere often called for covering mirrors after someone died. One belief was that the spirit could become confused or trapped in the reflection. According to the Myrtles legend, one mirror was left uncovered after a death in the house.
That is where the folklore really takes off.
Why the Story Endures

The Myrtles survives as a ghost story because it has almost everything people expect from a haunted Southern mansion.
You have an old plantation, family deaths, violence, slavery, Civil War history, ghost sightings, mysterious footsteps, and a mirror people are still talking about generations later.
But the most interesting part is how difficult it can be to separate documented history from stories added later.
The Chloe legend is a perfect example. There may be no surviving record proving she existed, but her story is now one of the best-known parts of the Myrtles.
That is how folklore works.
A story gets repeated, details are added, visitors experience something they cannot explain, and suddenly the legend becomes part of the place whether a historian can document every part of it or not.
The haunted mirror works the same way. People already know the old belief about covering mirrors after a death. So when they hear that this particular mirror may have been left uncovered, everything that happens around it takes on another meaning.
A smudge is no longer just a smudge.
And once someone tells you the mirror watches back, it becomes very hard not to look.
In This Episode
- The history of the Myrtles Plantation in St. Francisville, Louisiana
- David Bradford and the original Laurel Grove plantation
- Deaths and tragedies connected with the house
- The famous legend of Chloe
- William Drew Winter and the Myrtles staircase story
- Southern mourning customs involving mirrors
- The folklore surrounding the Myrtles haunted mirror
- Why history and ghost stories become so difficult to separate
The Myrtles Plantation is a good example of what happens when real history and supernatural folklore live in the same house for long enough.
Some stories can be documented. Others cannot. But visitors continue reporting strange experiences, and the legends keep growing.
The full episode looks deeper into Chloe, the staircase, the mirror, and the old beliefs about reflections and the dead that helped make this Louisiana plantation one of the most famous haunted houses in America.
And if you ever visit, you may find yourself doing what thousands of people have done before you.
Looking into that mirror just a little longer than you intended.



Knives have been used in magical traditions all over the world.
One of the best-known Appalachian death omens is the mysterious knock.
Elva Zona Heaster married Erasmus Stribbling Trout Shue, who went by Edward, only a few months before her death.
Robert Johnson was born in Hazlehurst, Mississippi, in 1911. Early stories about him don’t describe the incredible guitarist people remember today. Then he disappeared for a while and returned playing remarkably well.